Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Smallville, JSA, and Comic News

Smallville: JSA: During the winter weather here in NC, I was in Greensboro. I spent the week shoveling snow, chauffeuring my mother to and from work as well as following up a lead on an imaging job. My girlfriend's basic cable doesn't get a lot of channels outside the main networks (no USA, TNT, TBS) and frequently wasn't home until 9 so missed quite a few shows. So, I really made a point of wanting to be in the house by 8 on Friday to catch Smallville to see the JSA two-parter.

If anyone else tried to watch it in the Triad area on Friday, they know what happened. For some reason, right at 8, the CW went off the air. There was no message transmitting an error or "technical difficulties", it was just a blank screen. Right at 9, it came on again, as far as I know with just as much an explanation. Luckily, my brother was taping the show, so I held off on watching it until I returned to Raleigh the following Tuesday.

Not a bad episode, they managed to get far more of the JSA in there than I expected. And the characters at least looked the part for the most part. There were nice touches in that the heroes Green Arrow dealt with most in the episode were Hawkman (the SA/post-post Crisis versions he had a long-standing rivalry with) and Star-Girl/Star Spangled Kid II (the GA versions of both characters having served on the same team in the 40s). It was nice to see the return of the Martian Manhunter character, giving the show a bit of a JLA-JSA team-up feel. Also had the various characters pairing off to follow-up leads, another nice little homage to the GA JSA books.

The bad? Well, the whole plotting was basically WATCHMEN-lite, with the original heroes being compromised and forced into retirement (although Hawkman's rendition as to the whyfores, evoked a SA tale that explained why the JSA went into retirement over turning over their secret identities) and are currently grizzled shells of themselves. As it's written by Geoff Johns, it's his Conan-the-barbarian Hawkman that is on the screen here and it is obvious that the character doesn't make a good leader and so there's emphasis on that as a plot point. Likewise, you get Johns' pet character Stargirl over all other candidates for legacy heroes: Sandy, Kiku, any Infinitor, or even the original Star-Spangled Kid himself. You also have deaths of classic characters where actual killing off the characters aren't really needed. It's a shame that Wesley Dodds was killed as the character of Sandman would be a natural for a tv series. According to the painting, the JSA had a Black Canary as a member while Green Arrow's little group also has a Black Canary but no mention is made of that.

Sadly, as much of the story revolves around Hawkman, his character was also the weakest. The actor did a fine job but much of the failure revolved around the writing, costuming and effects. Typical of modern writing, Hawkman throws Green Arrow through a stained glass window, just glossing over what that would actually do to a person. No wonder Arrow doesn't like him for the rest of the show, he basically just used potentially lethal force (at the best, leaving physical scars for life) on someone for no reason. Hawkman flies way too fast and is depicted as a blur, probably to gloss over the lack of budget to actually portray him using his wings flying in a more organic, natural manner. The breast plate wasn't a bad idea, but it appears sculpted for another actor as instead of making the character look powerful, it makes him look fat. As far as costumes go, they did a better job on the Roast of the Superfriends in the 70s.

The story had holes in it as well such as why would Checkmate actually ok an operation to assassinate the very heroes they think they will need in the near future? The whole thing to force them out of retirement just doesn't ring true as just bringing their history to light might have done the same thing without actually killing several of the members and possibly compromising Checkmate in the process. And the villain used to kill off more experienced heroes was just lame. At least make it a group or someone that seems to have cred. Instead, it just makes you wonder how they lived as long as they did.

And, making Tess Mercer a former agent? Ugh. The character already is serving as too many plot points with connections to everyone around. What is needed is a bit more fleshing out of her character, more insight to her motivations and actions without yet another little hidden tidbit of her history. Just when was she supposed to be an agent in her already over-filled past?

Also tiresome, the incessant references to Clark's "destiny". It's just bad cliched writing much as the characters in the DCU actually treating Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman as some sort of holy trinity. It's one thing when Jor-El was harping on it, because his idea of Clark's destiny was at odds with Clark's journey of discovering where his humanity was with all of his powers. It had conflict. But, when other characters keep talking about him as being a savior and better than the rest, it's just tired. What's interesting is when we SEE it, when he refuses to give up on someone's possible redemption, when he tries to find a way that doesn't involve taking a life, and when he bounces back after failing or experiencing the cost that comes from living up to standards and ideals. We don't need characters telling us he's great and destined for bigger things, we already know he's supposed to become Superman. It also robs us of Clark as a character as it reinforces the idea of Superman as the iconic hero and not a flesh and blood character. Whereas the show best succeeds when it is about the characters and their relationships and foibles.

Comic News
There's actually some good news out there. DC and Geoff Johns plans on bringing Aquaman back. Although I hope that the David Finch artwork is just for the cover and not the interior. Hopefully it will be the Geoff Johns that brought Green Lantern back and not the Geoff Johns that wrote Hawkman, Flash: Rebirth, etc. He talks about using continuity like he did with Hawkman, but his use of continuity for the most part is to warp and darken it and treating characters more as plot points than as people. His Hawkman owed more to Robinson's non-continuity tale The Golden-Age than it did with any version of Hawkman from before. As James Robinson has had little to nothing to do with Aquaman, we can have hope that we'll be spared some of those tendencies to mimic Robinson's little ticks.

Meanwhile, Stan Lee and Tom DeFalco are teaming up with Archie Comics to bring some new superheroes. As DeFalco is one of the few writers that actually writes unapologetic superhero comics with superheroes and supervillains and well-rounded casts of characters, there's a lot of potential that this could be a fun series that's all-ages without actually being written for eight year olds ala Marvel Adventures.

Marvel seems to have be taking a few steps at addressing some of the problems themselves with their most recent announcement of an Astonishing line. So much of the bulk of their line is so continuity heavy and so dependent on being up on everything going on in several other titles, that it alienates readers that don't want to follow every cross-over title or four Spider-man books a month. At the same time, readers don't want to be ghetto'ed either, forced to read books that don't have anything to do with the main continuity. If I want to read Spider-man, I want to read about THE Spider-man, not some other version with a different history or that's been dumbed down. It's sad that it has taken this long and that it still misses the boat somewhat in that it's taking what used to be true for the bulk of the line and sidelined it into a handful of titles. It sidesteps the bamboozle of when the Ultimate line was introduced. It too was supposed to be more reader friendly but on the basis that by starting from scratch readers wouldn't have to worry about past continuity. Except that once you have a second issue, you have continuity and so many of the other books at least required knowledge of continuity to get the full impart of the stories as they set out to introduce as many characters and elements of the original continuity as possible only with more post-modern sensibilities.

Have to give Marvel credit. They have managed to predominate the comic news lately. What's really noteworthy is that they did so for two weeks with basically one story just doled out a little bit at a time.

1) Bendis announced that all of the Avengers titles would be ending. Of course what was kept hidden was the obvious news: that there would be several Avengers titles relaunching with new issue #1's.

2) Marvel announces that the Dark Reign would be ending and that the heroes would be returning to their roles. There would be a new Avengers #1, this time with Iron Man, Thor, Captain America and Hawkeye as members once again. This is a bit disingenuous as I'll show in a bit. However, is this really news? Dark Reign ending? All stories and story arcs have endings. And if it is ending, then it makes sense that all the Dark Reign titles would be gone and that the heroes would be taking the spotlight again. This is like a forecast that says it will be snowing tomorrow and then adds it will also be cold and wet. What Quesada and company don't say is that there will actually be a shift or change in tone to the stories but many ravenous fans moan about the Disney-fying of Marvel. There won't be. It's still the Bendis and Brubaker show. Later announcements prove to bear this out.

2a) Other misleading comments as Quesada talks about how it's not a response to the Disney buyout, that this was long before in the works. I don't claim to have any special knowledge and it may be true that it's not a response to Disney, however it's a straw argument that Quesada puts forth. The business deal had been talked about as a possibility well over a year ago, it's hardly been a secret. Turnaround in publishing and on producing comics and major story arcs are potentially far quicker than that. Or does Quesada really want us to believe that they can plan something and have it in the works for going on two years AND STILL SCREW UP THE SCHEDULING OF THE ISSUES AND COME OUT LATE?

3) Now, day by day we get teaser images of who will be in this new Avengers. Of the teaser images, Spiderwoman is the only one whom we weren't already told would be an Avenger. See? It's non-news. What is news but no-one treats as such is the misinformation being fed to us. We were told it would be Cap, Iron Man, and Thor on the same team once again. Only it's not. Because, it's not Steve Rogers Captain America but the Bucky-turned commando/assassin Captain America. So, all that talk about the return of the heroes... nah, not really true. It's the same old shell game. If it was USAgent as Cap, Rhodes as Iron Man, and Eric Masterson as Thor, would you still say it it's the return of the big three to the team? No. Because as good as they are, they haven't served together before as the team nor had time to fully establish themselves as THE characters.

4) Oh look, we're releasing another Avengers title, the Secret Avengers written by Brubaker. So, that big announcement by Bendis about all the Avengers titles going away... yeah, we'll just glut the market with a bunch more.

5) As part of the "Heroic Age", Agents of Atlas will be returning. You know, that team of heroes that betrayed their country, took over a terrorist organization and allied themselves with its members who have attacked and killed American citizens and feed badguys to the dragon they ally themselves with. You know, all written by the guy that managed to sap much of the larger than life and sense of fun out of characters like Marvel Boy called the Uranian and is appropriately colored in gray as that's how interesting he's become. And, they'll be teaming up with the now dull 3-D Man who at least when he was Triathlon he managed to homage the classic character without actually usurping the original id. That took talent and creativity. Making Triathlon into 3-D Man is just an old cliche and managing to rob us of having two separate viable characters.

Welcome to the new boss. Same as the old boss...

But, after two weeks of news blitzes, what we got was bascially: Dark Reign is coming to an end as all stories must and with it, all the titles that had been focusing on the villains passing themselves off in the identities of heroes. As the heroes take the lead again, Avengers will be restarted with a new #1. Again. Bendis will continue writing and Brubaker will also be writing an Avenger title so if you like what's been done so far you will continue to do so as nothing else is really changing.

Kevin Smith made the news. When I first saw the headline that he'd been made to leave the plane, I figured it almost had to be his language. Instead it's because of his size. I can sympathize with him to a degree. America has this interesting double standard. It's the most obese country in the world while at the same time, obese people are one of the last few groups that is fair game to obviously ridicule and marginalize. To the point, that comedians like the late Chris Farley build their whole comedic persona on self image immolation. Drug addicts and smokers tend to get more sympathetic treatment.

Meanwhile, Dynamite has revealed that in an issue of their new Green Hornet comic that a character will die. Forever. It's interesting news on several fronts. One, the first issue hasn't even come out yet and they are trying to build interest on an issue after that. Two, it speaks of four characters: the original Green Hornet, his son the current Hornet and the two Katos. Now, if it is really the original Green Hornet and Kato, they'd be in their 90s by now. I assume the company is taking the stance that the one from the 1960s was the "original". But, that's hardly the same as being the "original". And, it's hard for any to be the original or real deal when you're talking about a licensed characters. They are all Dynamite's versions of the characters. But, if they aren't using the actual history, then they're not really the characters that appeared in radio, movies, comic books and television. Case in point, the "original" Green Hornet has already been killed off once before, in the 1990's series by Now Comics (that also gave us a female Kato, so far Smith's story is sounding quite familiar). So, Dynamite cannot really kill off the character "forever" anymore than they could the characters in Project Superpowers. The next company that comes along will probably just ignore Dynamite's storylines and do their own take. They may decide that the Green Hornet and Kato somehow time-skip to the present day ala the Seven Soldiers of Victory, Captain America, etc

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Television Shows


Human Target: About as much to do with the DC Comics character as the show “Bones” has to do with the characters of Kathy Reich’s novels. Makes you wonder why they bother to pay money for the licensing. They are not keeping the core concept and the character is not popular enough to have resonance outside of a subset of comic fans. Just call him Target and save the money.

I understand the premise of the comic is dicey for the show, that Chance disguises himself as the target. It would mean either having guest-stars would be starring as Chance other than a few scenes and the plots centering around characters that are similar to the main actor’s build. But, that is the whole point of the character’s concept. Otherwise, he’s just a bodyguard. Plus, the show didn’t bother to have him disguise himself at all. Three different missions are shown (though only the middle one is the main story) which translates to three different undercover roles. Not only does he not disguise himself, he does not even bother to change his persona. Look at shows like “Leverage”, “Burn Notice”, "Dollhouse" and “Hustle” where you at least have the leads taking on various personas slipping in and out of their established characters with ease. Or Val Kilmer as “The Saint” at how to handle disguising. But, it requires a strong and convincing actor. John Noble does a wonderful bit of it on a recent episode of "Fringe". Playing the normally mentally unstable Walter Bishop with a childlike glee, he briefly gets all of his mental facilities back and his face and voice undergo a subtle hardening transformation and moments later he shifts back again.

There were a few other missteps The music for the opening was flat, didn’t really match the animation or feel. After all the build-up of the tension of the parachuting out the back of the train (and shown in half the commercials) the actual effect is over so fast, if you blink you’d miss it. I did. The scene with the icecubes was just done in one of the last episodes of “Monk” and what was the deal of leaving a drink suspected of being poison behind for someone else to drink? Lastly, the final extra scene felt flat and waste of a great actor in a small cameo.

What’s left is actually a decent action television show and is at least fun to watch. Mark Valley as Christopher Chance fits comfortably as an action hero and pulls off his scenes competently. He plays the role with a bit of roguish charm. Meanwhile, Jackie Earle Haley steals every scene he’s in as Guerrero, a slight and unassuming character but with an undercurrent of being the most dangerous man in the room. Chi McBride does decent with what little he’s given, but it’s so little, his character and that of Guerrero could have easily been combined into one. If they are cutting costs with production, at least quality actors and guest-stars are gotten. Looking forward to seeing the beautiful Moon Bloodgood in an upcoming episode.

The second episode was a bit more outlandish. The pilot was a train about to crash, now it's a plane. Chi McBride is given more to do than just being a foil for the other characters.

Many series start off a bit weak, taking a couple of episodes, sometimes a season to gel. So, I have hopes for it. Just please change that opening music.

Sanctuary: Late coming to this series, I’ve only seen a handful of episodes. Luckily, one of those was an episode the season finale builds off of. Having been to Mumbai, India, the finale had an added draw. It took me a while to figure what was off with the depiction of the slums. They and the inhabitants were just too clean. Even new and kept-up buildings have grime and soot and litter is everywhere. I loved when Zimmerman broke out in a Bollywood influenced dance to communicate with Kali. A wonderful and fun touch. Needed an actual song though. Callum Blue who has been playing General Zod over in “Smallville” does a great job as a villain here as well. The only thing that really bothered me was just how easy the bad guys are able to track Zimmerman down. We’re not talking a small town. Yet the slums and all the action are apparently within walking distance of the India equivalent of the Sanctuary.

Dollhouse: I tried to get into this show but never could. Doesn’t really surprise me it was cancelled. It suffered from a similar problem that afflicted “My Own Worst Enemy”. Neither show really explains the advantages and whys of all the hoops the mysterious Agency jumps through to mentally warp the main characters. To have mysterious goals and agendas is fine. However, the viewer should still be able to grasp some idea of the payoff, why it’s more beneficial than just hiring the right people for the job. Both shows highlighted the pitfalls but not the gains. With “Dollhouse” it seemed like a lot of effort to create what was used for the most part as an upscale escort agency. Another good example of a show that allowed the main characters to step into different personas each week and making it work though.

BBC has a new show, “Demons”. Sort of a serious English version of “Buffy the Vampire Slayer”. Entertaining way to fill in the time until “Primeval” and “Being Human” return.

Comics
Green Hornet: Kevin Smith gives an interview concerning how he came to be doing the Green Hornet. The interviewer didn’t bother to clean up any of his language, if this was on television, the buzzer they use for expletives would have been worn out. He doesn’t even try to come off sounding like a professional but just a fanboy with a mouth. This isn’t the first time that comicbook resources has posted something with strong language without the least bit of warning or advisory. It’s the type of thing that could one day bite them in the posterior regions. No excuse for it, except it shows the same type of unprofessional mentality that Smith is portraying. It also has the opposite effect on me concerning the title that he is supposed to be promoting. Instead of exciting me, it turns me off the whole project. I would like to see someone tackle the Green Hornet that just forgets the Bruce Lee as Kato and remember that it’s the Green Hornet who is the hero, he should be the equivalent of Batman or the Shadow with Kato being his helper and friend. Kato shouldn’t overshadow the Hornet. And, the whole revision of Kato as a woman, just covering the same ground in the decent Now Comics version.

Liberty Company: Started writing creatively again. Liberty Company chronicles the public domain heroes in World War II, least ways starting off. Who knows where it’ll take me.

Gnome Chronicles:
Also started a Fantasy Novel. The beginnings of it are here.

It's nice to exercise those mental muscles again.

Friday, January 08, 2010

New Year, new musings, a War of the Gods?

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!

Been a busy one for me. Driving to and from Greensboro for extended weekends. A little writing. A little job searching. Some reading. Due to unemployment, mostly agreed to not really exchange monetary gifts this year. For my girlfriend, I wrote a poem, and took some photos of us from different trips and events with friends and family over the last 3 years including trips to the beach, the mountains and to India and placed them in a scrapbook. Some were serious and some were silly and some a little bittersweet such as my cat Fred who I had to put to sleep this past year.

I got three great comic related gifts. From my gal, a large Peanuts hardback "Celebrating 60 Years". It doesn't contain every Peanuts strip but does have thousands of them. Included are also quotes as to what Sparky thought about when he created different characters and concepts, what fueled the variety of stories such as why Snoopy fights the Red Baron and why Schroeder idolizes Beethoven. And, there are strips I remember from childhood books but not seen since such as the time Snoopy's doghouse burns down. Did you know he had a Van Gogh? Also from her, a collection of "Mutts" strips. "Mutts" and "Get Fuzzy" are probably my two favorite modern day strips and pretty much what I miss most from not seeing the daily newspaper although I do get to read "Get Fuzzy" from time to time when visiting and I pick up "The Rhinoceros Times". From her nephew a signed collection of Chad Carpenter's Tundra comic strip. Her sister's family lives in Alaska where Chad is from and his strip is set. So, for the last two years, he goes to a book signing and picks up the latest book for me. It's funny stuff though she claims it's very guy humor. She might be right. My brother and I laugh out loud at the same strips and she just rolls her eyes. You can check it out online at http://www.tundracomics.com/

Going into the new year and Steven Grant has done his last Permanent Damage column while Erik Larsen has started a column over at comicbookresources. I'm going to miss Grant's column. I didn't always agree with him, but he often made you think. And, he had some unique insight into comics and the business. He chooses to end with his last few columns on the one subject that we are in absolute agreement: Gil Kane's wonderful art and especially his Western covers. It's not the first time that he broached the subject and I think it was Grant that pointed out the first time why Kane's covers (and much of his splash pages and climactic scenes inside) work to such a degree. Kane uses all three planes of the page: the background, midground and foreground. All artists do to a degree, but Kane had the panes communicate with each other, action crossed the various panes. The background wasn't merely scenery, the action didn't just take place in the midground, the foreground often was so much at the surface of the plane that it involved the reader as if he was part of the scene. He also turned the camera 90 degrees. Instead of looking at a scene of action perpendicular that read from left to right, his action moved from back to front and back again, the action coming towards the reader as if everything was for a 3-D comic. It's what gives his covers and art power. Kane also mined other tricks to show emotion or to transcend just the three planes such as the "up the nose" shots of heads often looking omniscently from the air above a scene. It's not meant as a literal depiction of the scene but a way of presenting several sides of a scene in one panel and to heighten the emotional response. I won't say Kane was the perfect comicbook artist. I think there's a reason why he rarely did team books or ones that contained heroes with the sole power of superspeed. And, the few times he drew the FF, it seemed an uncomfortable fit. But, when it came to drawing cosmic and sci-fi heroes and Westerns, he was the tops. There are times I wonder about the companies and creators. Kane was a name that had enough of a draw that one would think to just have centered a book around him. Separate him from the mainstream ongoing continuity and just have him work with writers on various characters from their vast history as well as creating new characters. Get him to draw the Shining Knight one month, the Western Johnny Thunder, and the JSA Johnny Thunder another, then Space Ranger, the Simon & Kirby Manhunter and the Demon after that.

Larsen seems to be a little more in line with what I think but I think he suffers a bit of diarrhea of the mouth, he often says or presents things in ways guaranteed to get some kind of response and often causing people to really miss the point of what he's saying. Especially, this week's column judging from most of the responses. As it has come down to people defending their buying the monthlies vs. the trades when what he was talking about was the need for the monthlies to get back to the point that they can stand on their own. How many titles have you dropped just because there wasn't enough there in the monthly comic? Even when telling a multi-part story, each issue also has to carry enough to make it a satisfying read on its own. But, as more and more writers write for the trade, the stories have become so long and stretched out, there's not enough meat in a single issue. No beginning, middle or end. In other words, to wait for the trades should be a financial decision but not because the story is written in such a way that it's read better that way. I recently read in one forum about a disgruntled Captain America reader, that he kept trying Brubaker's Cap in the monthly format but kept turning away. He lately became a fan because he got a whole bunch of the comics at one time in a deal. When he was able to read a large chunk of them at one time, it made him appreciate what Brubaker was doing. I couldn't help but think that was a bit of a backhanded compliment, though. Because it meant that on a month-to-month basis, Brubaker was failing him as a creator because the story that was being told was not being properly told, delivering enough story to really draw him in and care in short installments. I know it was one of the factors for me. It is also one of the factors that have lead me to stop getting BPRD and Hellboy books that Mignola doesn't have a direct hand in. The stories drag on too long and ramble a bit too much. I often feel that they would be best read in one sitting and if that's the case, why get the monthlies?

Larsen also nails why anthologies should work yet often don't (and why Wednesday Comics didn't work for me, by the way). Again, it's about making sure there's enough story in there to warrant getting the book, to not just rely on the lead story or lead character. Make sure that you're delivering a satisfying read for the money each and every issue. An anthology needs more than just one story to draw the reader in, he should want to read about half or two thirds of the stories in it, all of which need not be a complete story but it should be a complete narrative and not just a bite. You can make Detective an anthology, with the lead story being twice as long as the others, usually complete or a two-three parter while backed up by various other stories by top creators, such as Gotham Central, Batgirl, Man-bat. Some of which would be done in one short stories and some longer serialized features over 6 to 12 months. The model I'm thinking of is the old 100 Page Giants the books used to be as well as Batman Family and Superman Family. Ever try to find those at affordable prices these days? The Goodwin-Simonson Manhunter storyline from those days has been a gold-mine for DC not only in reprints but in how many storylines and characters have drawn inspiration from it. And, it was just a measly little back-up strip by two barely known creators with a forgotten character.

Comic Reviews

One of the dangers of not blogging in a while, comics get forgotten about and not talked about. You know, one of my favorite things to rant and rave about.
Black Coat: The mini has come to an end and America is on the precipice of war with England. Black Coat has to come up with a cure for his immortality since it carries with it a curse of madness as well as defeat the agent of a secret mystical brotherhood that is engineering the war. It's wonderful stuff! Set against the historical backdrop of the American Revolution, it lends a certain inevitability/fatality to the story. While certain people don't want war and others are fighting against being manipulated though they recognize the war as necessary, on some level you know that the war is going to happen regardless of their actions. The best they can hope for is that the wrong people don't profit from it. The story mines Mignola territory but there's more subtlety to it. There is intrigue and action. Likewise, it mines Captain America and Batman territory, but the story moves at a more brisk pace with plenty of action and the hero more engaging than either of those have been in ages. If this book was an ongoing monthly, I could probably be easily happy with just reading it and Astro City.

Hellboy: Bride of Hell: I commented before how I am not a big fan of Richard Corben's artwork but with Hellboy it's a great fit. His detailed yet stark contrasts works perfectly with Mignola's characters and storytelling. This comic is also a complete story in one issue, harkening back to classic Hellboy (and older horror comics' stories) as a tale of mood and dread yet with a quick rhythm and pace. Also contained is an excerpt of Guy Davis' Marquis which I might have to try to find at some point.
Julie Walker is the Phantom: I don't mind spending a little extra when the book is something like this. Longer than a regular comic, with a full story, wonderful artwork AND appropriate coloring! For those who came in late, Julie Walker was the twin sister of the Phantom of the late 1800's and when her brother is incapacitated she puts on the costume though no one ever comments on why the Phantom should change sexes. This story involves real-life reporter and crusader Nellie Bly recreating Phineas Fogg's trip around the world in less than 80 days. However, a man that has been inconvenienced by her previous articles decides that at some point, she should suffer a fatal accident on this trip. When the Phantom breaks a leg stopping the first attempt, his sister takes over secretly guarding Nellie Bly. The subtext of women's lib and sexism runs through the story but without actually taking over or being preachy and stands as a good superhero story against the historical backdrop. While I don't know if it's intentional or not, it also raises the question of other branches to the Phantom line. Julie is mentioned as being married and having kids, which means there's at least one more line to the Phantom heritage. It might suggest why in the 20th Century, there'd be other characters to adopt Phantom like m.o.s, if you take a Wold Newtonian view of comicbook characters.

JSA: One of the things I'm not liking about the JSA books is how they split up the stories and such. In others words, a big part of the plotting of the last several months of the JSA books is basically getting covered now in the split-off book. If you want to find out the villain behind the attacks of the gang of supervillains and why they were not going after Stargirl, you got to get the other book. While the attack by Kid Karnevil against Mr. Terrific and Obsidian's reduction to an egg and being taken is covered in the main book. And, a different big villain is brought back to fight the JSA while that story continues as a subplot since they cannot go after the big villain of the other plotline, even though that's what was driving the book for the last few months. I like the division in that it allows me to get just one book and it allows more characterization, but this is a bit backasswards. The bringing Mordru in as a big threat villain for the team to immediately face should have gone into the new book as the new threat while the ongoing plotline actually gets addressed in the book that it started.

Otherwise, the newest issue has art that is straightforward and tells the story well. There are funny bits as people think that Liberty Bell and Hourman being on different teams means they broke up, and Mr. Terrific balking at inactivity while he recovers, a light-hearted touch often missing in many of today's comics. The deal with Mr. America's whip fell flat as it turned a decent and non-lethal weapon into a weapon that would be lethal against anyone this side of Solomon Grundy and he wouldn't be able to use it to disarm, as an impromptu swing line, etc.

JSA ALL-STARS: Not really getting this book, but my brother picked up my comics this week, and they placed this in my bag since I do get the JSA. I like the cover, specifically the coloring style. Sadly, that's the best thing to recommend this book. My brother made the comment that the artist might need to get laid a bit more often. While Power girl's chest has always been a bit robust and is part of her thing, the artist pretty much draws the Asian Judomaster, villain Tigress and teenager Stargirl with the same proportions! In this book we have the modern tendency to take last seen colorful characters in new, mundane and colorless outfits ie Arthur Pemberton. Also on hand is to treat his last appearance apparently was in real time since he's now 30 years older since then. Bleh. The back-up story also has a few mis-steps. The Tigress and Icesickle are two of the villains in the lead story but also in the back-up. No one could be bothered to possibly create NEW villains to use instead of trotting out the same ones over and over. And poor Johnny Quick who isn't even in the story, they manage to completely mischaracterize as a big part of the motivation serving the story is that he had a "Speed Force" fixation. Only he didn't. He believed in his magic formula and the Meta-Gene explanation NOT the Speed Force and apparently often butted heads with Max Mercury over it. In fact, until Wally's accessing the Speed Force and Johnny's being absorbed by it, Max Mercury was portrayed as being the only one of the heroes to believe in it. So, Jesse Quick would not have been told any bed-time stories about it.

JSA Blackest Night: Did not get this, but it was in my bag the other week so I leafed through it and considered it. Ultimately, saw it was a mini by James Robinson who hasn't impressed me enough to buy anything lately and not a one-shot, and I'm not getting any of the other BN tie-ins, so there. But, in it Damage is dead? Yet in All-Stars he's fine. So, either he dies at some point in the future of the JSA books or he recovers from his dead status here. See, the JSA annual does set up the fact that something serious happens to Damage and could die, that's nice foreshadowing and setting up of tension and dread. This is just removing the teeth from that future story as we now know the outcome. The Annual was fairly weak, it might have been better if the whole comic was made to be about Damage's death instead of character vignettes (though the Damage one was nice and moody while the rest pretty much forgettable).

Superpowers: The latest issue is the lull before the storm. The villain is revealed as is his plot and the heroes put together a plan and position themselves while the villains behind the scene bicker. While I have lauded the story for moving at a faster pace this go around, this issue raises some of the same flaws that plagued the first one. Characters are made to fit the story and logical extrapolations are bypassed to tell the story the way the writers want to instead of following internal story logic. Captain Future is revealed as Zeus who wants the Promethean fire stolen from him back. An interesting idea but so far it isn't really explained as to how and why he became Captain Future or if there ever was a real Captain Future. Nor, why he would choose this scheme, and if he was behind the Pandora's urn angle that trapped the heroes for decades and why he'd fall for it himself.

Just as in Chapter One, the Lama was made into a full-blown magician instead of using characters who WERE full blown magicians, this issue makes some characters into adversaries for Zeus while ignoring all the mythological heroes actually available. Samson makes some sense, but Twister is given a mythological origin as a descendant of Odysseus AND cursed by a wind god. Admittedly, as far as I know he was never given a real back story, but it just seems a little pat, whereas another character from the 1940s who hasn't appeared was Tornado Tom. Tom had been picked up by a tornado and deposited hundreds of miles away and left a victim of amnesia and now with tornado powers. If a character suggested being cursed, it was he. Not to mention if you wanted a hero with abilities descended from a Greek hero there was the Nedor hero Thesson, descended from Theseus and with a ring that grants him super strength and endurance. Meanwhile the Flame and Flame Girl whose mastery over flame given to them by those friendly Tibetan monks are made to tie in to the Greek myth. Acceptable enough. However, what gets ignored are characters like Vulcan who has been captured by the cabal that is helping Zeus. They feed him Flame Girl when they have a hero who claims to be descended from the Greek gods themselves. Part of that group are other characters like Lash Lightning and Lightning Girl who got their lightning based powers from the mystic Old Man of the Pyramid, the Sword who received powers through Excalibur and others with no origins and pseudo mystical underpinnings such as Captain Courageous and Unknown Soldier. Also serving them through President West is Man of War, a being created by Mars and imbued with the powers of the greek gods including a flaming sword. Meanwhile, Man-Cat (nee Cat-man) got his abilities from a Cat goddess. Other GA characters with powers from the gods: Diana the Huntress (the actual goddess given the mission by Zeus to fight Nazis in Greece), Thor (the Fox hero given the weapons of Thor and his powers by the Norse gods), Craig Carter (Centaur hero with a ring that allows him to call forth the gods including Zeus to serve him). As well as various heroes empowered by various spirits like the Fighting Yank: Captain Red Cross, Yankee Girl, Major Victory, Captain Fearless, Citizen Smith, Steel Fist, the Flag (also in service with other patriots to the President and the cabal) and then a host of other mystically powered heroes. And, there's ole Hercules himself who pops up enough in various GA companies that an appearance wouldn't be out of the question.

Lastly, what about Mars himself? Mars who was a villain in the Fiction House titles. Mars who was a villain and accidentally created a hero in Man of War and spent time trying to destroy him. You have a precedent with Mars, using the actual history and stories that this series is supposed to be celebrating. By making the villain Zeus, it raises the question why him and why not an actual GA bad-guy god? Or at least other dark gods such as Shiva, Loki, or Set whose pantheons are not as extensively intertwined already with the heroes and history. It's a case where the story hasn't sufficiently explained the motivations behind the extreme actions. As it sets forth to cast a character against type, the explanation given is weak and raises other questions. By making the changes to characters to use the ones they did use, it calls attention to all of the other characters that would have made more sense or at least the equal amount of sense to use, even with ones that have already appeared at least in cameos. It calls forth questions in its internal inconsistencies instead of presenting a story that makes sense.

What is sad is there really is a story hidden in this, that is logically extrapolated from the series central conceit that all of the GA heroes of the various public domain companies were active in one continuity, the question of the plethora of mystical based superheroes. Why at this time the gods of various pantheons and mystics got involved in the War, that all these heroes and villains would receive powers from them and places like Tibet. What about this World War involves restless spirits of the American Revolution, Far Eastern mystics who would pass knowledge and powers on to those of European descent, the resurrection of mummies on both sides, etc. And, keep in mind that it has to have been seen coming for decades, people like Amazing Man and the Flame were raised in Tibet from infants.

Marvels Project: With the fourth issue, I stopped getting this title. In four issues, we've had the deaths of three characters. What is sad, is that none of them are well done and they all serve the same purpose, to motivate the actions of the Angel who is ostensibly the central character of the book. With the death of the Two-Gun Kid we had what seemed to be a cool moment that makes no sense in regards to character motivation, why his "friends" would send him as an old man to a time period he never lived in, where he had no friends or family away from friends and family he probably cultivated in the 40 years he lived in the future, and where medicine and treatments were a hundred years out of date. With the death of the Phantom Bullet, it was completely off panel, we never get to see or know the character and the Angel's actions and reactions are not supported by the story. We don't know why he takes it so personal or why he thinks the death was in some way involved with a case the Phantom was working beyond getting killed while stopping a crime he had just come across. Then, we have the death of the Ferret. The Ferret's death serves the exact same purpose of the Phantom Bullet's to the point that nothing is gained. The Ferret could have easily just as been wounded/placed in the hospital. It violates a story that otherwise fit into continuity from just a few months back that has the Ferret living at least long enough for the Human Torch and Namor to become uneasy allies. This time, we find out there is a friendship between the Ferret and the Angel that existed somewhere in between the panels of the books though it's important enough to serve as explanation for the Angel to take personally. Lastly, it's a death that pretty much demeans the Ferret in its treatment. The deal with the Ferret is he's a pulp styled detective, an ace detective. But, from his handling here, it gives the reader more of the idea that he's just merely eccentric and lame enough that he cannot handle a simple shadowing job and is very easily killed. In order to build up the Angel as a character, the Ferret (and to a degree, the Phantom Bullet) come across as ineffectual, characters to make jokes about. It's a storytelling tactic that seems a recurring theme in Brubaker's writing. I had hoped this would be different, it started off strong enough. But, this was enough to call it quits on his writing. I hate it because he otherwise handles characters, themes and time periods that interest me. But, we obviously get different enjoyment from them.