Adventures of Superman #3: Got this as more of a protest buy, to support a more classic take of Superman. The art looked passable, if over the top and definitely over-computer colored. 30, 20 years ago, this story might have been considered pretty good. It's exploring some of the same ground that Alan Moore used to do and Busiek does regularly, but unfortunately it fails miserably at it. The conceit is that it is a look in the day of life of Superman, talking about how other people dream of flying, which of course he doesn't.
One of the problems is that it is setting up a false premise in order to turn it on its ear. In this case, to explore how Superman is not like us, only to make him all that human at the end. Except, the whole set up does too good a job at alienating us from Superman. He's too super, too beyond human concerns for the twist at the end to pay off.
The other is conflicting themes. Again and again, it talks about flying. But, the story is really about how FAST Superman is. He flies to an inhabited world under his own power, he does all these various big epic adventures in under an hour, he can hear super-fast, move so fast to be invisible, etc. If taken place on Earth, it would be a Flash story.
Last, there's just a lot of stupid writing going on. It would be invisible to a kid reading it, but keep in mind this is a "serious" story, it's meant for us to THINK about Superman and what it would be like to be Superman. He can hear things we can, and thus pick and choose what he responds to. He hears a call from an alien Green Lantern and flies across millions of miles in minutes. Then, he doesn't wait for an explanation but just does his own thing. Why she calls him and not a score of Green Lanterns that might be closer? Who knows.
He then stops a war on an alien planet. Here the writer shows Superman acting with complete naivete in his approach to stopping the war. Not to mention that it raises the ugly head if he can do that on an alien planet, why can he not put an end to wars here? Because, the reality is war cannot be stopped or resolved in that simple of a manner. Plus, Superman is lucky in that he can recognize what alien libraries look like, can decipher their language and styles instantly and that this advanced race still uses books with pages!
Then he's basically kidnapped to Apokolips. This section isn't really written badly but it does show shortcomings of the artist. He gets the characters to look more or less on model, but nothing about Apokolips looks Kirby-esque. You'd think most artists would leap at the chance to design a couple of alien worlds and races on their own AND be able to riff on Kirby, but nothing there. Then he gets back to Earth to save some un-named man from being shot and Lois from being blown up (another badly drawn scene as the action of that panel moves from right to left while we read left to right so it takes a second look to actually read the scene correctly).
What's really funny is how this comic could be lampooned. Superman constantly acts, but is too busy to stop and analyze, too busy to talk to anyone. His walking Lois Lane to work takes precedence over actually talking or taking time to think. It results in almost disaster at several points and makes Superman seem more of a Super-prick know-it-all busybody butt-insky. By the time, I was done I had in my head comments being made by all the other characters, of how he actually screwed everything up and made things worse, not better.
A good idea and germ of a story... sloppy execution on every front though.
Astro City So good to have this back as part of my regular reading material. Busiek does a good job at updating, acknowledging that time has passed for characters, especially after the really long arcs. The first issue is an interesting look at Gaiman/Morrison-esque weirdness and meta-fiction and followed by a two parter looking at the support staff for Honor Guard, who fields the phone calls asking for help. Solid storytelling by Busiek and Brent Anderson, again the weakest part being the coloring, often too dark or working too hard to make faces and things look 3-D or realistic which only competes with line-work.
Buck Rogers Ok, this comic is pretty much complete crap. See, on Free Comic Book Day, they released a free comic featuring a classic Buck Rogers story. While a little primitive in style, that story was amazing complex, creative and dense. I can only assume that it was released to show that it's 180 from the direction they were going. Knowing Chaykin was involved, knew it was going to largely depend on which Chaykin showed up. The Chaykin that likes pulp related stuff or the one that cannot resist in twisting it, making it adult and somewhat sleazy.
While Chaykin at least gives Buck a perm so that he looks differently from American Flagg/Dominic Fortune/Blackhawk/Nick Fury, his Buck is the same prickish thug that he normally writes. Actually, that's not fair. Buck is a fanatical Communist prickish thug who even actually calls someone "comrade". Not making this up.
On the very first page we have swearing. Nothing extreme, very moderate,
but to not even get past a first page... Then on the second, we have a
nice blood splatter from a breaking nose. A little more swearing and a
couple bloody exploding heads later, the writing is pretty much on the
wall. I'm not a prude, swearing and blood & gore is fine if you're
doing a comic like The Walking Dead. When it's applied to Buck Rogers, it comes across as superficial, trying to be edgy without providing content of substance to justify it. What's funny is that some words are more acceptable than others as when this version of Black Barney swears while using a current day exclamation it gets symbolized: What kind of chicken#%*s outfit is this? Seriously, that's where you draw the line?
The plot is a bit back to basics, but it is not only simplistic, instead of making Buck different from Flash Gordon, it makes him MORE like him by taking his storyline: that the various gangs of people left over from America are too busy fighting each other that they will not unite against their common foe and it's going to take Buck to do so. Now, the original stories you did have the Han taking over America and the people existing in small groups called orgs or gangs. But, the problem was of disparity of technology, strategy and tactics. It was Buck's knowledge and experience as a veteran that made him into a leader able to organize the groups into effective fighting units not the groups fighting amongst themselves.
The comic has the honor of being one of those that I really wish I could return and ask for my money back.
Captain Midnight Another return of a really old character. Fairly solid story dealing with the man suddenly yanked from his past and discovers a complex world. Because of a secret mission he was on and the time travel involved, he's sorta wanted by the Government because of stuff he knows. Of course, he apparently doesn't trust people because of what he knows as well. It's a bit Captain America crossed with Nick Fury and James Bond and an enjoyable comic. The only really stupid part is when some of the agents go rogue, they gain glowing green skulls and no one reacts to this. They are shocked that the men are traitors, but not by the glowing green skull heads?
Five Ghosts The book often feels as if being written backwards, constantly giving information or story developments that should have probably occurred earlier in the book. In this case, we get a major revelation in the last issue just how unsympathetic and criminal of a character that Fabian was before his curse as he's shown to willing betray a partner and shoot him in the back over a treasure. The art and its storytelling continues to be top notch, but as a mini-series it reads like a rough draft. Trying to be clever with its structure and doling out secrets but not really organic or doing so in the best possible way. The announcement at the end promises it to continue from this mini as an ongoing and I really want to like it as it is full of potential. But, the writer needs to actually write, get at the meat of the story and not rely so much on the art.
Half Past Danger Another mini-series with a great high concept: WWII, island of dinosaurs and an Irishman, a super strong Yank, a British woman and a Japanese Ninja go to it and fight the dinosaurs and figure out what the Nazis want with them. Sadly, the writing isn't quite up to par. The first issue alone, we have the Irishman leading a platoon on the island. His squad gets eaten and he comes back but it seems as if he's not believed and so he's drinking himself to death until he meets up with the Yank and Britisher and a bar room brawl begins. It gives us the set-up and the major points of the plot, but what it doesn't tell is the STORY. We don't get to know the individual soldiers, they aren't drawn or written in any distinctive way to tell them apart or to care for them or their relationship with the leader. The author needs to go back and read some of those old war comics by Robert Kanigher and see what he actually did in so few pages. Just because it's a multiple part story doesn't mean that the individual issue shouldn't have its own story to tell, that you should care for the characters beyond laughing at the kewl bits of attitude. And, someone should kick the colorist in the butt and tell him to stop doing color knockouts on a blond person's head but nowhere else. It makes his hair look like it belongs to a different sort of reality than the rest of his head and body and the hair of everybody else.
Overall, it is a fun comic mini in that it's a bit like a roller-coaster ride. But, it reads like it's being written or developed for hopes for a film offer such as a SyFy Channel movie.
Dynamite Comics After watching Masks slowly circle the drain and go down the tubes, really wanted to bail on them, but they followed up with some intriguing comics, doing a bit more right than wrong for a change.
Lords of Mars Tarzan goes to Mars. Ugly cover as it looks like Ross has been taking lessons from Jusko and delivers such muscular men that one can only wonder how they move. Whereas, the insides has a pretty competent and clear artist drawing characters with lean muscular bodies. For comics these days, the heroes almost look emaciated, especially compared to the cover! There's great character moments introducing the main characters and there is some story contained here. It's decompressed, Tarzan doesn't end on Mars by the last panel. However, there is good groundwork and mystery that's established, to let you know that more is going on than readily meets the eye. The decompression is not to stretch out a thin story, but to tell it and fill it. Now, if it can keep that clarity in art and storytelling and not peter out by the end like the Gulliver of Mars and John Carter team-up in Warriors of Mars.
The Owl Yet another old hero that finds himself coping with the present day. Here, they show that they've learned from the Black Terror series in that we see Nick Terry aka The Owl dealing with personal issues. He's trying to get a job and figure out his place in the modern world. He is dealing with real ramifications of having everyone and everything he knows being gone, having moved on without him. There are some hiccups in the writing. Apparently, the writer has never applied for a real job beyond retail as he seems to think that someone would turn in a resume and get an interview if the company wasn't looking to fill a position. Not to mention that getting a job as a policeman is not the same as getting a normal job. As the Owl he seems to have purpose, but when he finds a modern Owl-Girl who is far more violent and keeps the money she takes from the crooks, he has to wonder how much the world has changed and not for the better. It's a bit of a false premise. The 1940s comics and heroes were NOT the sanitized ones from the mid 1950s and 60s. This isn't necessarily something that would be so abhorrent to him, even if he disagreed with it. And, the redesigned costume and powers/tricks aren't really an improvement. But, these days I'll settle for a simply average superhero comic where the hero is about being better than the bad guys and wanting to do the right thing.
Shadow - Green Hornet: Dark Knights Ignoring that they met in Masks, this series presents them as meeting again for first time. Written by Michael Uslan, it starts off strong as far as the writing is concerned. He knows the history of the characters and the time period and works a lot of it in without resorting to simply name dropping (and notes in the back explaining some of those bits). You have to deal with the fact that apparently the Shadow's ring is some super-power source/weapon maguffin for the plot. He does an admirable job at presenting the Green Hornet/Britt Reid as being a peer of the Shadow/Lamont Cranston and juggling the similarities and differences of the characters. There's the Shadow suspicious of Kato's loyalties while Shiwan Khan thinks a crook like Green Hornet with an Asian side-kick would make him prone to team up with him (in the 1940s, there were a few issues where the Green Hornet does pretend to team-up with a Japanese spy leading the Black Dragon Society).
The artwork is detailed but often dark, confusing and inconsistent on people and is the weakest part of the book.
Then, there's the implied lesbian relationship between Margo Lane and Lenore Case. Apparently, knowing each other years before when their men leave them to make excuses to each other to cover their secret identities, they decide to talk about the "bad old days" over wine. When we next see Margo, it's when Harry is calling on her at her hotel room and there's some naked buttocks going by in the room behind her. Nice cuckolding the men heroes there that is completely purposeless. And, that sexual fantasy attitude that women are just a bottle of wine from enjoying a lesbian encounter.
Wednesday, August 21, 2013
Comic Reviews
Posted by
cash_gorman
at
4:29 PM
0
comments
Labels: Buck Rogers, Captain Midnight, Dynamite Comics, green hornet, superman, Tarzan, the Owl, the Shadow
Tuesday, December 04, 2012
Masks and other comics
Masks #1: A solid if unexceptional first issue focusing mostly on the Shadow and the Green Hornet and Kato and laying down the foundation of the threat, of the "Party of Justice" taking over control of the city of New York, its police and courts. Likewise, the painted artwork by Alex Ross is pretty to look at. I personally chose the Francavilla cover. He is one of the stronger artists with a more unique style and approach to layouts and colors and perfectly suited to the pulp and noir storytelling feeling of such a book.
I don't know much about the particular Spider novels that serve as the inspiration and source for the plotline. Kudos to Dynamite to running an ad for places to get more about it. However, I've read several that have a similar set-up and feel.
There are questionable things concerning it, still. The story is to feature the Black Bat and we see him as Tony Quinn his alter-ego here. However, it's from the time before he was blinded and became the Black Bat. He's one of the few pulp heroes whose origin is pretty much given and does not leave much wiggle room to fit in another epic. In his pulp origin, he's a lawyer as seen here, only is blinded by a criminal who smuggled in some acid (the chemical not the drug). An act that will seem familiar to most comic fans as that's the origin for both Two-Face and Dr. Mid-nite. He retires from Law and becomes a recluse. He's visited by the daughter of a slain sheriff and agrees to an eye-transplant with the lawman's eyes. The operation is a success and leaves him with the extra ability to see in the dark, though he still has the acid scars around the eyes. With the sheriff's daughter and two other aides, he decides to let the world to continue think he's blind while he remains retired, acting as a sometimes consultant and the masked and costumed vigilante the Black Bat.
Nor does this crossover actually line up with the portrayals of the Spider in his own comic. Visually, he looks the same, but this is set in the late 1930s and his pulp novel while the main series is full of retcons and set in the present day. Time will tell if his supporting cast will be at least truer to the pulps or to the retcons. The story continues the Bruce Lee influence of Kato, which makes it hard for Green Hornet to seem really a peer of the likes of the Shadow and Spider.
Conversely, the upcoming covers featuring the Black Terror have him in his classic costume and not Alex Ross' redesign. But, Miss Fury is being shown in a re-designed costume.
Storywise, the main thing that doesn't really add up is the discussion between Britt Reid and Lamont Cranston concerning Law and Justice. Thematically, it fits as the Party of Justice is about a group taking over and subverting the law with criminals being enforcers and agents of the new corrupt laws, leading to men of justice becoming outlaws. However, the discussion doesn't really fit. Reid as the Green Hornet is a man who fosters the idea of him as a criminal, to act outside of the Law. If he truly believed in the Law over Justice, he wouldn't be a masked vigilante but fight solely from within the system as a crusading newspaper publisher. It's a scene for the sake of the story and not growing out of the characters.
Otherwise, the writing is solid. It introduces the heroes, a brief hero vs hero fight (though it should be the Shadow vs Green Hornet, Shadow vs Kato is akin to Batman fighting Bucky or Captain America fighting Robin... even the tv show got that right and had Kato fighting Robin), A discussion of the heroes in civilian identities over the problem. We get the introduction or teases of a couple of other characters but otherwise see the criminal group in action, enforcing the new laws. Ends with the heroes fighting overwhelming odds and the addition of another hero to the ranks. The writing is tight. It doesn't try to introduce every character at once. Where it does offer glimpses of future heroes, it's in scenes that also serve in showcasing the corruption of the Party of Justice and building storytelling tension. There's talking, but also plenty of superhero action.
While Ross did the artwork on the first issue, he's not the artist on the subsequent issues and as far as I know the future artist hasn't been announced. The cynic in me is so that retailers and readers will have to commit at least to the first couple of issues. Ross is a good painter. However, he's not a great storyteller. Panel flow is often clunky and he overuses his trick of casting the viewpoint beneath the characters to make them seem larger than life. Combined with tilting the angles of the panels making it seem some heroes are flying and shifting the viewpoints from low to high can cause a bit motion sickness. It feels as he's almost approaching each panel individually without much regard to the storyflow from panel to panel. His Lamont Cranston looks like an old man, and I've never found his women to be all that attractive. So, the scene of the Cranston and Margo in the Cobalt Club doesn't really give a feeling of jazz, glamour, or sophistication.
There are many that don't see a problem with the portrayal of women in comics. One can look no further than this comic to see the gap and issue. This comic will feature heroes from pulps, radio and comics the Shadow, Spider, Green Hornet and Kato, Zorro, Green Lama, Black Bat, the Black Terror and Miss Fury. Among all those men, one woman out of all of comics and pulps from the era though there are several that would fit. Instead of the oddballs such as Zorro and the over-powered Black Terror, women heroes like pulp's Domino Lady and comics Woman in Red, Invisible Scarlet O'Neil or Phantom Lady would better fit. To add insult to injury, one of the alternate covers of the first issue featuring Miss Fury is her half out of costume as is one of the future alternate titles. There is no similar depiction of any of the male heroes.
There are a few other male pulp heroes I wouldn't mind seeing over the Black Terror and Zorro either: Jim Anthony, Phantom Detective, the Black Hood, Angel Detective, the Park Avenue Hunt Club, Operator 5, the Avenger, Secret Agent "X", the Crimson Clown, the Ghost, the Purple Scar, Skull-killer and the Octopus/Scorpion. Maybe the latter can be the next story. A sequel to the the Octopus and Scorpion pulps, clearing up some of those loose ends and having the two villains teaming up with Wu Fang bringing various pulp heroes together again.
Another big flaw is that at the price of comics today... the first page is wasted to a black title page with credits and acknowledgements. The second page is all black with the publisher information at the bottom... the story doesn't start til page 3!!? Why aren't those two pages just one page? Or better yet, at the bottom of one of the story pages as most comics do? Sure, that would mean reducing a page of Ross' artwork or putting non-story text on it, but it would free up two more pages for art. At the very least, print some of the alternate covers, original pulp covers or sketches on the pages. Seriously, an all black page at the front of the book? Before I even began the story I had a bad taste in my mouth.
Talon #2: Ok, second issue (or 3rd if you count the zero issue) and there's a guest-artist? Right on the heels of Snyder online praising the work of the artist. I'm out.
Aquaman #14: Like Masks, a set-up issue, following up the the events of the last issue and setting up the next arc. It tells us what happened with Black Manta, though not a single mention of The Others.
This issue has been billed as a good jumping on point, but it's not really. Because, for the most part it is incredibly dull with a lot of talking and Aquaman not doing much. We get some heavy handed dialogue as to why Aquaman is cool and tough, while Black Manta turns down an offer to join the Suicide Squad. Only, there's nothing to tell new readers who or what the Suicide Squad is. There's a tease in dialogue concerning Garth. However, as this is a new reality, how much this Garth will be like the old Garth remains to be seen. A long dialogue between Ocean Master and Aquaman concerning past events. A scene with Vulko as an Atlantean body washes onshore conveniently near where he's been in exile. A bunch of disparate scenes, with little to tie any of them together, especially if you've not been following the title and very little action, but a whole lot of talking. The only scene with oomph is Black Manta asserting his Bad @$$-ery while in prison while talking about Aquaman and turning down the Suicide Squad.
Posted by
cash_gorman
at
9:31 AM
0
comments
Labels: Alex Ross, aquaman, Black Bat, comics, DC, Dynamite Comics, Francesco Francavilla, green hornet, Masks, Miss Fury, the Shadow
Thursday, July 02, 2009
Belated Reviews
For a few weeks, I'd been on vacation with my gal and her family. During that time we went to Washington DC where I was able to devote a couple of days to doing research on copyrights of the various comic book companies in the 1930s, 40s, and 50s. My main goal was to look into the issues surrounding Quality Comics as well as Fawcett. The first draft of an article about my findings are up at my site if you aren't a regular reader there. I plan on revising it some in the near future to expand on the Fawcett and Charlton information as well as including Magazine Enterprises. Though I can tell you now, in a nutshell, none of their comics were renewed.
Like so many people, I went and saw the Transformers movie. Luckily it was a matinee. On one hand it looked pretty good. John Turturro is always fun to watch on the screen. The humor in places just went on too long (the mom eating a hash brownie was a needless scene as it serves no purpose) but for the most part didn't offend me as much as other viewers. Part of me is willing to accept this is a movie based on toys and about giant fighting robots and so is solidly aimed kids and teenagers. There's going to be a lotta sophomoric material. I can accept that. However, that's no excuse to deliver a movie whose whole plot hinges on a plot hole so that it doesn't make a lick of sense. Your average Scooby Doo cartoon has tighter plotting and structure. Factor in things like going out the back door of the Aerospace museum in DC shows an airplane graveyard with MOUNTAINS in the background. Then there are just scenes that threw me completely out of the movie moments apart: giant robot holds car in air with hero hanging on outside for dear life, girlfriend and roommate inside said car. Car is dropped from somewhere between 20 to 50 feet to the ground yet it hits the ground with all the force of dropping 5 feet. Hero is somehow now inside the car, front airbags go off and everyone gets out of the car with no trouble (even the roommate in the backseat). Then the hero is picked up, flung through the air twenty feet across the room and lands on his back onto a solid concrete floor with a huge metal bolt sticking up. It hurts him for about 2 minutes, but these two incidents back to back should pretty much completely incapacitate him for the rest of the movie if not for life. Which wouldn't have bothered me too much. Each of the Transporter movies have at least one scene that completely violates any semblance of realism it has going for it. But, when you factor in that the whole movie is this level of stupidity and attention to detail... I've seen a lot of bad movies in my life, but none that are so blatant in just plain laziness at actually trying to tell a story.
Comics
Quite a few mini-series have wrapped up featuring various GA characters which makes for an optimum time to look back on them.
Angel - Blood & Trenches: Overall a great and fun little mini-series. Byrne's artwork and writing perfectly suited for horror and a period piece like this. The production of the book seems a bit sub-par this time around though. Shooting from pencils is a ticklish beast. On the one hand, it can give the work a more energetic feel with more gradations and depth that disappears when translated to inked lines. However, it can also look incomplete or not show up properly when printed (there is a reason the pencils are inked after all). This is what plagues this issue. The resolution and contrast in the printing loses the subtle pencils exacerbated by putting much of the pencils on gray backgrounds. A shame really, as the earlier issues were so powerful. Still, a fun read.
Avengers/Invaders: You know, part of me wonders if Marvel just doesn't want the Invaders to succeed as a concept. The last revival was hobbled from the start by debuting in a title that was on the way down by a creative team whose stars were waning. It's already a niche book, but to make things even more difficult that right after the launch a completely different creative team handles the ongoing. The writer was unproven with few comicbook credits to his name while the artist had a completely non-traditional style. Little surprise that it didn't find an audience.
This time out, the powers that be chose to shoot the pages from the pencils, apparently without telling the penciler that. Halfway through, a second penciller is brought in to handle some of the book but no rhyme or reason to the pages he does to the pages that Sadowski does and the styles are hardly similar as the other penciler's work is completely inked. For the first several issues, the coloring or the separations were sub-par leading to purplish blues and magenta reds. Even Ross' covers often seemed to be printed a bit dark and murky.
I give Krueger credit in the writing that he was trying something novel in that it would seem about 2/3 of the way through that the story had been resolved to lead in to a completely different threat. However, it seems that to pad the book out so that it had more than one ongoing story and to give enough space to deal with Stark's unspoken guilt over the fate of Captain America, Toro discovering his fate and to play up Bucky. Krueger thus gives us the side story of the LMD uprising and their mystery leader to stretch things out. But, like Michael Bay's movie, the plot makes little sense and Krueger never really explains things. Maybe, he realized that the story was out of his control which was why we get the GA Vision halfway through to serve as Sir Exposition concerning the Cosmic Cube. Sure, it really has nothing to do with how the Vision has ever been presented before and he does next to nothing because his job here is to be narrator and he's the only cosmic hero of the time available.
The big surprise/twist at the end of the series even has quite a bit of the power robbed from it as it was more or less revealed in the promo blurbs for the upcoming Human Torch mini-series.
Will give them props for having started AFTER JMS The Twelve yet manages to finish BEFORE that one with both minis having the same amount of issues and Krueger and Ross also working on Project: Superpowers for Dynamite.
Black Terror: Not a bad mini-series as far as the Project: Superpowers titles go. Written by Ross & Krueger, it suffers from the same faults of the other titles, tons of characters introduced and used without really bothering to explain them or their powers. Such as the various patriots helping President West and why they are such a threat (any one of them alone is as powerful as the Black Terror if not moreso, which makes one wonder how a tree is able to hold them immobile for longer than a second or two). While it is about the Black Terror's search for his kid partner it really is more of setting up the next Superpowers storyline. Thus, there is no real resolution to the story as far as President West and the Black Terror's attack are concerned for that's to play out in other comics. Meanwhile, we get a bunch of the kid sidekicks and kid heroes back (Yank & Doodle, Captain Battle Jr, Kitten, Boy King & Giant, Tim, Sparky, Davey). Interestingly, that of all the kids, only Tim's adult partner has been revealed as having returned. We've seen no signs of Black Owl, Captain Battle, Cat-Man, Blue Beetle and Magno other in the notes pages.
Death Defying Devil: Like his Last Defenders work, Joe Casey writes a mini-series that is about setting things up as opposed to resolving anything thus it ends in the last issue where it should have been in issue 2 or 3. As a story, it only raises questions as opposed to answering them (as opposed to the Black Terror mini that does resolve the central plot as set out in the first issue, what happened to the Terror's kid partner). Along the way, we are introduced to other GA heroes which is good because the Devil is not allowed to talk, write notes or think thoughts or anything else that might actually communicate a character to the reader instead of a cypher. Of course, this has to be, because otherwise we'd be able to get an answer to the big mystery: that the man that was DDD in the 1940s did not go into the urn and he is now dead. Thus, who is this version of DDD? Now this may be a nod to the fact that in the 1940s, Daredevil had two different origins. In his first issue, he was mute (and in a different colored costume), but was changed in subsequent comics. There was also a third character by the company with the same name as Daredevil's alter ego, Bart Hill. Maybe this is Dynamite's way of reconciling the different origins as there being more than one man wearing the costume.
The superhero plot is fairly undeveloped as the heroes (DDD, Ghost, and Silver Streak) rush to stop some plan by the Claw and his organization while DDD is stalked by a member of the former kid gang Wise Guys and who knows DDD's a fake. Swept under the rug is how the Wise Guy was able to conveniently find some organization willing and able to make him young and strong and supply a costume all at a moment's notice and then just let him go to hunt the hero down to settle his vendetta.
The artwork steadily improves over the issues but never really knocks it out of the park. Part of it could be that it too is being shot from pencils, but he's not really there yet as a penciler.
For a different look at the hero, over in the pages of Savage Dragon, Daredevil and the Wise Guys seem to have become semi-regular guest-stars/supporting cast. The treatment of the character is more light-hearted but doesn't ring any more true as it imparts a certain naivete and gosh-wowness to the hero, swinging a little too far in the opposite direction. Issue #148 even has a nice historical look at the character.
Masquerade: The best of the Superpowers minis as this one is truly character driven, filling in the gaps and background of the Miss Masque character leading up to how she got into the urn and a summation of the events immediately following her release (skirting the issues of US Jones' infatuation with her). There are a few cutesy scenes along the way but the storytelling otherwise serves the job well. If there is a weakness, it's that after all the issues setting her up as a capable heroine defined by her detective skills The painted coloring style does kill the wonderful job of the penciling underneath that was shown in the previews, making the artwork murkier as opposed to more attractive.
Project Superpowers: Chapter Two: Starts off with seeing how Captain Future was taken. It's a prime example of where no effort is made to utilize a character in keeping with who and how he was in the 1940s. While many of Standard/Nedor's characters were a bit generic, each did have unique elements that defined them. One of Captain Future's unique bits was that his erstwhile beautiful girlfriend ran a detective agency with her spinster looking aunt. With Captain Future only appearing in one page, how hard is it to make the character actually conform to simple basic elements of his GA stories? Instead of seeing him walking down the street with two un-named beautiful women on his arm, why not make them recognizeably the supporting characters from his stories? As is, the scene could actually be ANY character, it has absolutely nothing to do with the Captain Future character. A small detail to be sure, but a detail that shows that the creators actually approach the stories and scenes with an attempt at understanding the characters they write instead of the most generic presentation that requires no information other than the hero's basic look. At the end of the issue, the President stands revealed as the superhero Power Nelson.
Marvel Mystery Comics #01: The various 70th anniversary comics looking at Marvel's GA are a bit hit and miss. The Sub-Mariner one was excellent. The Human Torch does not work at all given what we know about the Torch's origins. Marvel Mystery has a wonderful painted cover of the Torch and Namor that is in keeping with painted covers by Schomburg of the time. The story is a sprawling epic of the 1940s that bring in the GA Angel, Electro, as well as the detective the Ferret to team up with Namor and the Human Torch against the Green Flame, old adversaries of the Human Torch. Then with some amazing thought by the editor involved, the stories reprinted are with the Human Torch against the Green Flame as well as the original Ferret story. Of course, look at Brubaker already planning on retconning various bits of these in his upcoming comic as he thinks the Angel's costume is really "lame" and is going to portray Electro as a "giant robot monster".
Sherlock Holmes: Two issues out of this mini by Dynamite. It sets out to tell a Holmes style mystery. The second issue starts with Holmes framed for murder and in prison while Watson and Lestrade try to do their best to carry on despite orders to stay away from the case as they are too close to Holmes.
Doing a mystery in a comic is always difficult because of the completely different pacing demands and presenting the detecting and the clues to solving the mystery in interesting graphic ways. One of the questions it has to answer is why tell this story in this medium? Holmes is a literary character and the bookshelves are full of pastiches and such. So, what is gained by telling this story in comicbook form? The writer and artist need to be able to address that question.
It's too early to judge the writing but the artwork is a bit stiff. His storytelling is solid, but uninspired. The artwork and depictions seem to indicate heavy use of models and photo references and using computer filters or lightboxing to draw over the figures. There is little sense of texture and just odd lines and ink blotches over faces and such that don't really impart meaningful detail but tend to make the panels seem more photographic in nature. The portrayal of Watson is in keeping with many of the films and giving us a Watson that looks quite a bit older than Holmes as opposed to two men roughly the same age.
Also disconcerting is reading a Sherlock Holmes story then going through the pages in the back and seeing the ad for Garth Ennis' The Boys with a hero soiling himself in fright. Everything else from stories to the other ads are all-ages appropriate except for this one graphic image. I was going to say that I found it hard to believe that no one saw that and thought it didn't really fit with the material of the book it was appearing in or at all appropriate. Then I realized I don't really find it that hard to believe at all. Just sad.
Justice Society America 27 & 28: After the sprawled out stories by Geoff Johns, we get a two parter written and drawn by Jerry Ordway, revisiting a villain from the All-Star Squadron days, the Japanese assassin Kung. In just the two issues, he manages to include a large chunk of the team's cast yet without feeling overly crowded and plenty of little character bits as well as telling a complete story that fits in seamlessly with what went before.
Captain Britain and MI13: Marvel is bringing this title to a close. While the writing has often been a bit problematic in its structure and inconsistencies in its exposition and dialogue (such as the purpose and definition of the team depends on the issue, or the fact that Dracula has a base on the moon is shown in one issue, but isn't explained how this is remotely possible until the following issue). Some secrets and mystery is good, but only if it is actually supposed to be and presented as such. Otherwise, it's actually sloppy writing that needs a little tightening up. However, despite its shortcomings, it has still been an entertaining title. Even when it started off in the midst of the crossover with Secret War, it remained secure in its own corner, not requiring reading half of Marvel's output to understand the book. Likewise the art has been solid and clear despite the best efforts of the colorist to muddy things up. The current storyline with Dracula has been great, making Dracula into a wonderful and natural master supervillain for the Marvel Universe. Under other writers, the team would still be fighting Skrulls these 14 issues later, the Dracula story would be a mega-crossover, hijacking a half dozen titles for half a year. Thus, despite its problems, this book is already more tightly written, full of drama and excitement than any two other books.
Pulps:
While DC is pursuing and planning on comicbook adventures of Doc Savage, the Shadow, and the Avenger, Sanctum Books is reprinting the pulp versions. Recently, they've added the Avenger and the Whisperer to their line-up. If you balk at collecting the Docs and Shadows due to their longevity, both of these notable characters had far shorter careers. The Whisperer is an interesting study as he has possible connections to different DC characters that Bill Finger worked on: The Whisperer is in reality police commissioner James "Wildcat" Gordon! The first volume of the Whisperer book contains two Whisperer novels, a Whisperer short story, an interesting essay on the genesis of the Whisperer character, an essay on Maxwell Grant and magic and another early pulp titled Crimebusters as well as a short-story featuring the magician sleuth Norgil whom Grant created for that title.
Posted by
cash_gorman
at
5:30 PM
4
comments
Labels: Avengers, Daredevil, Dynamite Publishing, Invaders, maxwell grant, Sherlock Holmes, the Shadow, transformers, washington
Monday, May 18, 2009
Doc Savage!
One of my favorite comics of all time is Marvel Two-in-One #21. It features a team-up between the Thing and Doc Savage, not a natural team-up considering the different worlds and time periods they operate in. It's a fun book and strangely enough, it works.
When Marvel had the rights to Doc Savage, they put out two versions. One was a color comic series that adapted some of the pulp stories with wonderful art by the dependable Ross Andru. The other was a b/w magazine sized book that featured all new stories. The latter was the better of the two.
In both, Marvel made a few concessions to the fact these were comic books, and Doc was a pseudo superhero. Not only was their more action, but Doc and his villains tended to at least look a bit super-heroic: the color comic with the vest and bare chest and arms and in the b/w magazine with a form fitting short sleeved shirt (though the covers followed the Bantam paperback covers by Bama lead and had him in ripped shirts) , all to maximize his musculature and the visual visceral action contained within the pages. Not really very true to the pulps, but, still, it more or less worked because they didn't really change the characters any. Now, years later and Marvel and DC are reprinting everything in sight, there has been a snag with all of those licensed comics Marvel did. See, Marvel had a habit of using the licensed characters as part of their continuity. With Doc, he only had two crossovers into the Marvel U., but both Micronauts and Rom interacted rather heavily with the rest of their universe. But, they no longer have the rights to those characters. This was a problem when Marvel Two-in-One was recently reprinted in the Essentials format. There is one issue missing, because Mavel couldn't or wouldn't pay extra for the rights to reprint that one team-up with Doc Savage. They can use Bug in Guardians of the Galaxy because the character was created for the Micronauts comic and not based on any toy as was the character Captain Universe.
You'd think that would be enough to give a publisher pause to pursuing and bringing in a character into continuity, especially these days with the secondary market of reprinting everything in trades. But, nope, DC is doing exactly that with Doc Savage. They did some comics in the 90s based on Doc Savage, the Shadow, and the Avenger which were a bit hit and miss. However, they didn't bring any of those characters into their continuity. In the 70s, when they had the Shadow and Avenger license, DC did have the Shadow cross over into a couple of Batman titles. One of those stories brought an angle to Batman that has been a key part of his persona ever since, his mania over not using guns.
Dan DiDio has said that Doc Savage will allow telling superhero stories from a completely different perspective. “The way Doc Savage works is that when he is in a world where people don't have superpowers, he becomes the superman of that world. You put him next to Superman, he's just a guy. He loses his value. A place needs to be created where he is the pinnacle of achievement, just as Superman is in the main DCU.”
Which is pretty much the whole problem in a nutshell. 20, 30 years ago when continuity wasn't so anal, DC was a little more forgiving at having multiple characters that overlapped their M.Os. You could have a Batman that operated in the same world as the Shadow, Doc Savage could exist on the same world as Reed Richards. There wasn't the need to have niches so narrowly defined that if Superman existed on a world, then everyone close to Superman had to be changed and/or marginalized ala Captain Atom and Captain Marvel. Doc wouldn't be able to exist at modern Marvel because he upsets the hierarchy of scientists, modern fans and creators are quick to point out that Henry Pym is stupid compared to Stark and Mr. Fantastic (and by default, Doctor Doom). Even 20 years ago, a Doc in continuity would have worked because stories weren't by default always about continuity, characters could operate in a corner of the world and be in continuity without having to constantly reference it ala Grell's Green Arrow and O'Neil's Question series. One could easily say that their modern day Doc Savage series was in-continuity in that it really doesn't contradict anything published in their comics elsewhere. For the purpose of his book, he's top gun and just let it go at that.
Add the other wrinkle that in the modern continuity universes, even the most basic scientist is able to build extra-dimensional rooms, teleporters, faster than light space-ships, Doc is going to need a serious upgrade to not come off as remedial next to every one else.
So, it would seem that I agree with Didio, but somehow I expect DC to still get it wrong. After all, they have with almost every other character. They recognize the problem, but not the solution. The solution is not to have to create some kind of world around him, but to simply focus on the character and write him true to that. Some concessions have to be made, it is a comic book. A super-hero comic book. And he now exists in a world where magic and such does exist. Not that Doc has to face mystical threats, but that he shouldn't discount magic out of hand as it was in the pulps. But, if you just concentrate on telling good Doc Savage stories and not fanfic of Doc meets superheroes, the continuity issues will take care of themselves.
The other problem is the same as with the MLJ, and Milestone heroes. Doc isn't needed in the DCU continuity. He doesn't bring anything but instead causes more head-aches and ultimately is marginalized because he is superfluous, a problem that Didio's comments would indicate that he recognizes but is continuing full steam ahead anyways. Doc DOES NOT ALLOW OTHER TYPES OF SUPERHERO STORIES TO BE TOLD BECAUSE DC ALREADY HAS CHARACTERS IN PLACE THAT CAN TELL THOSE STORIES. A hero that is the pinnacle of human achievement in detection and training? *cough* Batman *cough* both Mr. Terrifics, Paul Kirk Manhunter and his clone, Wildcat, the GA Atom, Mr. Scarlet, MLJ's Hangman and the Web. Science fiction style criminals, adventures and explorations with a team of exceptional but normal men: the original Challengers of the Unknown, Secret Six, Suicide Squad, Sea Devils, Atomic Knights, Blackhawks. Espionage tales with Superhero-esque twists: King Faraday, Sarge Steel, Nemesis, Checkmate, Human Target (coming to a small screen near you), the Unknown Soldier and pretty much all of the above. Super-science and gadget heroes: Ted Kord Blue Beetle, Odd Man, Mr. Terrific, Batman, MLJ's the Wizard, Challengers of the Uknown, Bulletman, Spy Smasher, Red Torpedo, the Blue Tracer, Technocrat. Like MLJ, Doc brings nothing to the table that DC hasn't already largely scrambled and squandered. Notice how many of those characters and concepts have been killed off, changed beyond recognition, or at the very least ignored. If they want to pursue Doc Savage because they want to tell some good Doc Savage comic book stories, that's great. But, focusing on making him part of the continuity, and they are approaching it all wrong-headed and don't impart much confidence because they haven't done too well with the characters they already have in continuity.
According to comments, they are looking at getting the Shadow as well. Same arguments apply. Although, if they are smart they'll get Gerard Jones and Eduardo Barretto to pick back up where they left off with The Shadow Strikes. From accounts, it was a profitable series for DC and a darn good one that incorporated the best of the pulps into the comics, but it was discontinued because Street & Smith increased the asking price for the license.
If they decide also get the Whisperer, one can just see how they reconcile his secret identity as Police Commissioner James "Wildcat" Gordon.
DC has released the promos for their upcoming comics. Here's how they describe JMS' Red Circle comics:
THE RED CIRCLE: THE HANGMAN #1
Written by J. Michael Straczynski
Art by Tom Derenick & Bill Sienkiewicz
Cover by Jesus Saiz
The Civil War claimed many lives…but one of those lives still hasn’t ended! Union doctor Robert Dickering found himself on the wrong side of the battle lines, and despite his heroic treatment of a fallen enemy soldier, he also found himself on the wrong end of a noose! But a shadowy power stepped forth in the twilit moments between life and death and offered him a deal he couldn’t refuse: to forever roam the Earth, saving the lives of innocents condemned like himself – or hastening the deaths of the guilty! But in taking the seemingly righteous mission of the Hangman, has he accepted God’s work? Or has he become the vengeful fist of the Devil himself? Featuring art by Tom Derenick and Bill Sienkiewicz, the acclaimed team behind REIGN IN HELL!
On sale August 5 • 32 pg, one shot, FC, $2.99 USTHE RED CIRCLE: INFERNO #1
Written by J. Michael Straczynski
Art by Greg Scott
Cover by Jesus Saiz
The mysterious stranger was brought into the hospital with one name on his lips: “Frank Verrano.” He has no memory of who he was, where he came from, or how he could possibly be the only survivor of a bombing attack on a cruise liner that killed hundreds of people. But as deep as that mystery runs, a violent attack on the hospital opens a deeper one. How can this man burst into flames…and survive? And why does the man who stands in those flames, the man know as the Inferno, look nothing like the one who stood in his place just seconds before? Blaze into this thrilling issue featuring art by Greg Scott (GOTHAM CENTRAL)!
THE RED CIRCLE: THE WEB #1
Written by J. Michael Straczynski
Art by Roger Robinson & Hilary Barta
Cover by Jesus Saiz
Billionaire John Raymond has it all – fame, fortune, and a brilliant mind! He also has a brother with the one trait John lacks: compassion. No matter how relentlessly awe-inspiring John’s achievements get, it’s his brother who’s always seen as the hero. So John sets out to upstage his brother one more time. He’ll show the world just how much heroism money can buy as the amazing (and suspiciously well-equipped) Web. But when a dark fate arrives for his brother, John learns first-hand what a hero leaves on the line, and that there are worse losses than the ones that hit your checkbook! Featuring art by Roger Robinson (THE BRAVE & THE BOLD, BATMAN: GOTHAM KNIGHTS)!
THE RED CIRCLE: THE SHIELD #1
Written by J. Michael Straczynski
Art by Scott McDaniel & Andy Owens
Cover by Jesus Saiz
Lieutenant Joe Higgins was dying in the dirt of a battlefield in Afghanistan when they whisked him away to a top-secret facility and saved his life with nanotechnology so experimental they couldn’t dare to use it on a living man. Now Higgins has been enlisted to a whole new mission – to be the public face of the American fighting man as the patriotic Shield! But today’s grueling military battles test the limits of patriotism and the limits of the technology that keeps him alive. And the shocking secret behind that technology may be too much for his bullet-riddled heart to bear. Featuring art from Marco Rudy (FINAL CRISIS)!
Yeah, that pretty much has NOTHING in common with the original characters other than their names. Takes balls to say otherwise. And, this should fill us with optimism over how they will handle incorporating Doc Savage into their continuity how?
DC has also announced that Steel will be on the backburner while Hardware is getting focused on with the bringing in the Milestone characters into continuity. Think I mentioned exactly that would happen. Although, it's not like we have seen much of Steel lately. A good thing that Mr. Terrific doesn't wear armor and is part of a decent selling team book or we'd probably see him also sidelined as well. We had Dale Gunn in JLDetroit who disappeared completely off scene once that team was considered an embarrassment, then Technocrat who was gone and forgotten once that version of Outsiders failed, then Steel and his star waned as Mr. Terrific's rose. And, amongst them we had Josiah Power and Skyrocket who didn't last long enough to threaten any of the others. Guess there's only so much room for African American versions of Tony Stark whether as a business man, intelligence level or super-power motifs.
DC's Wednesday Comics does look very interesting though. I wish there wasn't quite so much a focus on characters that already have their own books. I understand the need to have a few that are proven leaders, but 75% of it stars characters that already have outlets for their stories.
At Marvel, Howard Chaykin is returning to do Dominic Fortune set in the 30's. How cool is that?
Posted by
cash_gorman
at
5:01 PM
2
comments
Labels: Doc Savage, Dominic Fortune, Howard Chaykin, Red Circle, the Shadow, Wednesday Comics
Thursday, October 11, 2007
Captain America's Return and stuff


Marvel has just revealed a new Captain America debuting in January from Brubaker's glaciarly slow paced CAPTAIN AMERICA comic. This one carries a gun and a knife, so it's probably the bloodthirsty retconned alive and trained-assassin Bucky in the threads. But maybe not. As much as I generally like Alex Ross designs, the new Cap's big design change echoes another patriotic hero, the Shield. They say the triangular chest design is in homage to the shape of his first shield. However, I always heard the reason he switched to a round shield after his first adventure was from threat of lawsuit and trademark infringement of the MLJ (Archie) character whose costume it resembled. And when he was revamped when licensed to DC, his costume even went shiny!
Have to say, Alex Ross does a great Fighting Yank for the upcoming Dynamite series SUPERPOWERS. Of course part of that is it's accurate to the way the character looked and it ranks up there with some of Alex Schomburg's work with the character.
In the "Lying in the Gutters" column at Comicbookresources, we have a copy of an article revealing that Brandon Routh (Superman Returns) is in line for a movie based on the Italian Dylan Dog horror comic. What, Rupert Everett isn't available? See Rupert Everett starred in the movie CEMETARY MAN, based on a novel by the writer of Dylan Dog while Dylan's look is actually based on Rupert Everett. Dylan's comedic side-kick is none other than Groucho Marx, a similarity that had to be toned down in the American reprinting of some issues by Dark Horse Comics a few years back.
It’s the Golden-Age Again
It’s a good time to be a golden-age fan. Doc Savage and the Shadow are being reprinted again, with the original covers and interesting articles and insights to behind the stories. Did you know that overseas in England, the Shadow novels were heavily re-edited and names of the characters and such were changed to give them an England locale? If the story had a really strong or uniquely American flavor, they changed him to the Phantom Sheriff in the Old West! G-8 and the Spider have their facsimile editions regularly coming out, Adventure House still does High Adventure every other month, giving us all of the Captain Zero stories (very excellent by the way), Green Lama and Ki-gor stories. And there are other pulp facsimiles that come out such as SPICY MYSTERY, SUBMARINE STORIES, DON WINSLOW, etc.DC has had pretty good success with the JSA (even if it’s by killing off various golden-agers and replacing them with legacy characters, not matter how minor a hero). So, other companies seem to be getting on the bandwagon.
First, Marvel is revisiting various of their Timely GA heroes with THE TWELVE by J. Michael Straczynski and Chris Weston. In a nutshell, twelve of Timely’s GA characters get captured by the Nazis near the end of the war and placed in suspended animation for research. The end of the war interrupts things and they are on ice until the present day. Now, they have trouble adapting (some were killer vigilantes after all) and one or two may go bad and not all make it out alive. So it’s basically going “realistic” and making the heroes grim and gritty. Weston’s art is very detailed, but I find he relies on models just a bit too much. It saps his artwork of dynamism and everything tends to look too posed. Couple that with his realistic style errs on making everything mundane, playing up more the ugliness of the human form, it doesn’t go well with superheroes in general unless you ARE going for that grim, ugly, heroes as fascists theme that it seems all superhero comics have turned into. To see samples of the work, you can search on newsarama or go to Weston’s blog and search some of the archives from the summer: http://chrisweston.blogspot.com
Dynamite has hired Jim Kruegar and Alex Ross, fresh off of JUSTICE to also do a mini with various public domain golden-age heroes. Actually, Ross is only doing promo art, redesigns and covers, so you can stop drooling. The Fighting Yank takes center stage as a man today racked by guilt from something near the end of the War that lead to many of the heroes retiring and such. And he finds out he’s about to die and might have one last chance to change things. It’s a lot of revisionism, the golden-age Daredevil is the Death Defying Devil, Miss Masque is Masquerade, the Face is Mr. Face. The Green Lama at least keeps his name and looks close to his comic incarnation, but gets a complete power overhaul as he’s compared to Dr. Fate (the Lama was a pulp detective with very limited powers per se in the pulps, his radio show and his first round in comics. In his second round, he traded robes for tights and got Superman type physical powers). Again some retire, some die and some go bad. Where is the sense of fun that can be had with these characters?
Well, that might just be with Image and Erik Larsen as they launch something titled ISSUE AFTER NEXT. It’s various creators from today doing stories of public domain characters from the 40’s. Each creator is pretty much left to their own devices, so there’s bound to be a wide range of takes as we see Larsen on Samson, Allred on Madman, among others.
So, there are some interesting looking titles coming out that I have some hope for as being fun. And some that I’m just going to have to adopt a wait and see attitude.
Posted by
cash_gorman
at
2:08 PM
0
comments
Labels: Alex Ross, Captain America, Doc Savage, Dylan Dog, Golden age comics, irv novick, MLJ, Straczynski, Superpowers, the Shadow, The Twelve, Timely Comics
|

